Skip to main content

Brendan Gawlowski Prospects Chat 11/17/2026

Hello everybody — I need to take care of a quick thing so I will be starting this 10-15 minutes late. Apologies for the delay!

Okay, thanks for your patience

Just an update: Braves will run tomorrow. All the copy is in and has been edited.

For now, let's get to it.

Hey Brendan, enjoyed reading your Scouting in the Age of Machines piece. Have you given much thought or seen someone attempt to model how the value of additional dollars spent on scouting stacks up to other potential front office uses of budget (additional development personnel, another Trajekt Arc…)? I wonder if some front offices cutting scouting would not argue with your points in the absolute sense but perceive better ROI in other areas.

Glad you enjoyed it! I'm sure plenty of front offices have tried to make that exact calculation. Very difficult to estimate future ROI of an entire department, so as much as you want to model this, it's tough to do a with a whole lot of precision.

In reviewing the Braves, anything under the hood to remain excited about with Garrett Baumann? His fastball showed improved velo but his command took a big step back and he still needs another out pitch. On the plus side, he’s still only 22 all next year.

Yeah, I'd mostly stay patient with him. Stock down a tick year over year, but a lot of the fundamentals remain solid and sources within the org are still on him.

What are a few examples of realistic pieces Spencer Jones can fetch on the trade market given the context of the Yankees roster

A complicating factor here is that the Yankees valuation on Jones probably does not match what fans expect. It certainly didn't back when I was feeling that out in my Pirates days.

G'mornin, BG. Do you think the Mariners bounced back strong next season? Which prospect do you think will make the biggest impact this year, if any?

I think they'll bounce back, so much low hanging fruit there. Would help if they spent more ambitiously than they seem inclined to. Obvious answer is Anderson, who is still eligible, but I expect all of the late-season call ups (Arroyo, Kade, Laz) to get run

What do you think of the Grant Taylor/Didier Fuentes style handling of projected starting pitching prospects? Is the big league exposure out of the pen better for development than continuing to work as a starter in the minors or just teams wanting to squeeze MLB productivity out of them as soon as possible?

I thin it's fine. Tons of good starters have been developed that way for decades. And as we've seen with recent reliever conversions like Grant Holmes, Seth Lugo, maybe Morejon, etc. you can be a reliever for a while and still transition back to the rotation successfully.

When do you expect the Braves list to run? I'm afraid Fangraphs will go down alongside everything else in the country, but because I keep refreshing it.

Domani

Dammit Gawlowski! You’re a loose cannon! You gotta stop playing by your own rules or I’ll have your badge!

Welcome back, inspector

If you had to guess, how does the Dodger OF prospect logjam sort itself out? More trades on the horizon?

In the same way that Hope felt like a trade candidate for most of last year, I'm starting to get a similar vibe from Sirota. Purely speculation, but I see clean fits for De Paula (already arrived, will get run in a corner and can DH) and Davalan (utility) while Sirota's seems murkier.

You mentioned the Red Sox list is almost ready. What’s your final verdict on Arias v Story 2027?

Story starts, it works itself out.

He plays well: Great. He doesn't play well: You have a fallback.

Help settle a Brewer fan debate: At this stage of their prospectdom: Made or Chourio?

About the same, down to the fan fretting about ~average numbers at Double-A.

Who's a better third baseman in three years, Jackson Holliday or Jesus Baez (STL)?

I don't expect Holliday to be a third baseman in three years… so I guess Baez

With Bauers now out of the equation in Milwaukee which prospect do you think is most likely to log innings at first base for the Brewers next season between Luke Adams, Blake Burke, and Andrew Fischer?

Suspect all three have a chance, I'll go with Burke as the first out of the chute. Adams is the toughest fit given Vaughn's role.

Anthopolous recently appeared on Heyman's podcast where he said both Schwellenbach and Strider are "front line starters when healthy." How unreasonably optimistic is that on a scale of 1 to "Shane Baz's upside is a Cy Young Award winner" ?

Schwellenbach when healthy has been pretty close to that. Strider *was* but probably isn't anymore. It's optimistic but nothing crazy for an exec talking up his guys.

Hey Brendan -Thanks so much for the chat. Which of the following graduated outfield prospects would you like to acquire if you were running a major league franchise: Cam Smith, Ryan Waldschmidt, Braden Montgomery, Jason Dominguez, or Dylan Beavers

Waldy first, not a ton of separation on the four behind him.

Re: resource allocation and ROI, I think part of the issue too is that scouts (at least IMO) are prophylactic and help guard against non-experts misapplying their models (which happens eventually even to the most skilled modelers), which makes it harder to quantify the same way you might look at improved system swing decisions vs Trajekt hours, etc.

The value also isn't linear. One year, a scout or even a whole department might make very little impact. Another year, one conversation might prevent a franchise-altering mistake.

Flipside, which of the following prospects who had decent to strong debuts would you be most willing to move: De Paula, DeLauter, Montes, Carrigg, or Valdez (Pitt)?

I like all of these guys to varying degrees… I think the volatility in Montes/Valdez makes them especially movable if you get the right offer.

Do we think Ethan Salas starts most of next year for SDP?

I do.

After his 2026 season, how would you grade Waldschmidt now?

Still a 50 with a little more hit risk, better defense than I'd anticipated.

With Salas graduating from prospect status early next season. Who do you think the Padres next T100 prospect is?

Not in the org yet. They have guys who could get there, but I anticipate SD will trade the ones who pop before we can get them on there.

Dustin May – underperformed his prospect FV, overperformed, or just about right?

When on the field, about right with stretches ahead of that. But he missed so much time.

Could you give a tease of the Eric Hartman write-up? What have evaluators said about his late season swoon, and what kind of long-term upside does he have?

I think you'll be happy.

I think that post-grad updates (or continuing rankings for 2 seasons?) would be fantastic content at FG. I've messed around putting them in tiers myself, but obviously I'm no scout. Has this come up at all on your team? We follow players for half a decade and then 40 days into their MLB tenures the deeper scouting updates kind of dry up.

Bandwidth issue. Maybe something we can tackle better if we get the lists out before Opening Day.

Re Dustin may – wasn’t he a 60? Is he really what 60 performance looks like for a pitcher?

His 2019-2021 seasons were choppy but he was really good when he was out there.

Are we going to be graced with that deep baritone on pods more frequently?

I'm open to it. As for the voice itself… it divides opinion

With the rise of Hao-Yu Lee over the second half of 2026 paired with the departure of Gleyber, it feels like Detroit's left side of the infield may be unsolved at this point. Who would you expect to be paired with McGonigle at either 3B or SS to start next season between Max Anderson, Jace Jung, Trey Sweeney, or the field?

I'll take the field for '27. Feels like a good landing spot for someone like J.P. Crawford. Add a little reliability with the bat and some defensive versatility for a (presumably) low price as a bridge while you figure out how/where/if to play the young group.

How long will it take to evaluate Jeremy Bleich's work in AZ and how much different their pitching development is?

A couple years, but we can see trends (this group values extension, for instance). I'm a little concerned about how many guys lost velo year over year, need to dig into that as part of the research on the 2027 dbacks list.

Hey Brendan, with the nice season Rafe Perich had last year, do you see him contributing meaningfully to the Rangers this upcoming season if they decide to move on from Burger or Jung?

Maybe in the second half. I assume they won't move on from Jung, but if they did that would shift the ETA forecast up a little bit.

Do you think the Nats adding Susana to the 40 is more of an expectation that he contributes in 2027, or being conservative about a possible rule 5?

Both.

I think Bonemer is clearly the guy where FG is lowest relative to consensus. I've seen him in the low teens at other outlets while he's barely clinging to the list here.

Who is the reverse? I can't as easily pin someone you have much higher than the other major lists.

With the caveat that I haven't looked lately… some of the young or command guys, probably? Those are two groups Eric and I have challenged ourselves to stretch a little where we see talent. Maybe Keyner Martinez?

Is it fair to say the Blue Jays upper level pitching depth has gone from "a bunch of guys with functioning arms", to "actually, pretty decent"?

I don't know if it ever looked all that bad. Last year, Yesavage and Bloss were there… Obviously the development from King/Perry have enhanced the depth. Carlon kind of a wild card but I'd almost toss him into the upper level group, too.

Yordan Alvarez has become one of the best hitters in baseball. Is there ANY similarity between where Montes is now and where Alvarez was then before he blossomed? Or is just a body type, big cut comparison?

Sure. Very similar body types, both had massive raw power, both struck out and walked a lot. Adjust for era and Yordan's minor league strikeout numbers weren't crazy far off from Laz's.

(Obligatory "I do not EXPECT Laz to turn into Yordan" comment)

Apologies if you've answered this or written about it, but where do you land on the Salt River AFL experiment?

Interesting idea, liked seeing the outfielders have to go back on the ball, though it made the game more exciting. Didn't like stationing them near the lines, that part was goofy. Philosophically don't love making players stand in a particular spot, think the best way to get the good stuff without the hamfisted elements is to move the fences back.

Moving the fences back is kinda my skeleton key answer for a lot of stuff. Want a more athletic game? Move the fences back. Want more base hits? Fences. Best way to reduce the national deficit? Nothing that knocking a few outfield rows and pushing a fence back at Great American Ballpark can't fix.

Any scouting intel on the Mariners DSL prospects Pio, Rijo, or Gomez? They all performed fairly well from a numbers perspective…

They're excited internally, particularly on the first two

Does Hartman have number 1 prospect in baseball potential or is that just getting greedy? (also curious about Gillen and Angibel Gomez)

I see it more with Gillen than Hartman. Gomez's blend of youth and present ability gives him maybe the best shot of that group.

Echoing similar question for Dylan Dreiling with Evan Carter having hip surgery.

I don't really see Dreiling as a future regular. Don't get the sense that they do, either.

What is the probability that Aidan Miller or Josue Briceno earn a starting role by opening day despite losing most of last season to injury? Which has the higher offensive upside?

Opening Day? I think that's unlikely. Miller a little higher odds by default. Purely offensive upside, let's go Briceno because if he hits 35-40 bombs that'd be tough to top. And it's in there.

Luis Mey was the last pure relief prospect I can remember even sniffing the top 100. With the increasing use of multi-inning relievers and just non-traditional pitcher usage in general, do you think we'll see more guys with little to no "starting" experience considered top prospects?

For all practical purposes, I think we'll be grading Susana and Lagrange that way. And they could both be pretty high.

What did you think about Isaiah Drake while looking at the Braves org? Trajectory seemed pretty good before injury, but hard to read how AFL went

Slow burn. Swing looks better, he's just a guy who needs reps. A couple sources pushed him up the list as I was getting feedback.

And a second Reds question, do you think Tyson Lewis has any juice left? That K rate seems insurmountable

The alarm bells are ringing pretty loud but he's still a prospect. I suspect he'll slip to the 40 tier for us this winter.

Brendan! BP came out with their org ranking for the Cubs and slapped a 70fv on Hartshorn. 1) wut. 2) see “1)” 3) Is this real life?

Without commenting on any specific grades from another outlet, I want to make the broad point that… I think you guys would be shocked at the level of variance teams have internally on a lot of guys. Like, everyone thinks Made is good, but we'll have Top 50 guys this winter where different analysts/scouts/evaluators will have everything from a 40 to a 60 on.

Are teams as inclined to get trades involving major prospect capital done before the lockout begins, or is the rush mainly focused on free agency?

I don't know! Interesting question to chew on…

Re: Hartshorn also, they didn't give him a 70 lol, they gave him a 60 w/average risk, which is usually ~top 40ish for them

Let the record reflect ^^

Hartshorn specifically is the type of player who will generate a wide variance in opinion. Huge power, stiffer mover, performer, position risk… Lot of 'eye of the beholder' here.

For DSL/RK guys, do you have any inclination towards guys who have higher in-zone/swing rates? I've come to look positively towards the guys being more aggressive in the DSL because, if combined with a good approach, it means they are not being overly passive

We do. I don't wanna say there's nothing there but I think separating signal and noise on that at that level is very tricky and that there are other parts of a player's profile — athleticism, frame, present strength, etc. — that I care about a lot more.

If it's completely awful, that's one thing. Otherwise…

Is Robert Arias still a thing?

Yes, need to check in on his health.

In the ATL system — who do you like the most between Daniel Brooks and Brett Sears?

Sears.

Any of the various R5/40 man trades so far today caught your eye?

Cameron Foster getting claimed b/c it means I have work to do on a list I thought I was done with.

And on that note, I should probably go take care of that. Sorry to cut this off, but I want to make sure I take care of all the last minute roster stuff. Thanks as always for the questions, we'll do this again next week.

Source



* This article was originally published here

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Different Baseball Pitches

In baseball, a pitch is the demonstration of tossing a baseball toward home plate to begin a play. The term originates from the Knickerbocker Rules. Initially, the ball must be truly "pitched" underhand, as with pitching horseshoes. Overhand tossing was not permitted until 1884. The biomechanics of pitching have been concentrated on widely. The periods of tossing incorporate windup, early positioning, late positioning, early increasing speed, late quickening, deceleration, and take after through. Pitchers toss a mixture of pitches, each of which has a marginally distinctive speed, direction, development, hand position, wrist position and/or arm edge. These varieties are acquainted with confound the player in different ways, and at last guide the cautious group in getting the hitter or baserunners out. To get assortment, and consequently improve protective baseball procedure, the pitcher controls the hold on the ball at the purpose of discharge. Varieties in the hold caus...

Pitching Grips

Pitching Grips   Pitching holds pitching begins with the right grasp on the baseball. Here are probably the most widely recognized baseball pitching grasps and how I tossed them in school and expert baseball. Utilize these pitching hold portrayals and pictures as a manual for showing signs of improvement grasp on the baseball. Step by step instructions to Grip And Throw A Four Seam Fastball Step by step instructions to grasp and toss a four crease fastball - pitching holds for the four crease fastball Four-crease fastball To hold the four crease fastball, put your file and center fingertips straightforwardly on the opposite crease of the baseball. The "horseshoe crease" ought to confront into your ring finger of your tossing hand (as demonstrated in the photo on the left). I call it the horseshoe crease essentially in light of the fact that the crease itself resembles the state of a horseshoe. Next, spot your thumb specifically underneath the basebal...

7 Baseball Pitching Grips (Cheat Sheet Included!)

7 Baseball Pitching Grips (Cheat Sheet Included!)